The fake Toby Keith revealed...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a73b1/a73b1a233bf03dcab9fd54eabc31fdd1e9e70d47" alt=""
This is why it pains me to say that none of you are very good at correctly identifying Toby Keith lyrics. Greg came the closest in his correct identification of #3, but I’m almost certain that he was led in this direction by Tara’s earlier parenthetical guess. However, none of you accurately picked up on #5 as a Kevin-M original. You all felt that I was the author of the much less subtle and less heartbreaking #6 which is, alas, something that sprang from Toby Keith’s own mind. As did #1, #2, and #4.
It’s really too bad none of you won, because I was thinking of offering the victor a two week, all-expenses paid vacation at the Insomnia Report Getaway Villa, which is located on a dormant volcano on the leeward side of the isle of Capri. There you would have had access to the services of: Boris, my personal massage therapist; Cindy Quan, my “heart-smart” master chef; and Montez, my devoted driver/bodyguard. Although, if Greg won, I’d probably just send him to Liberia to hear General Butt Naked preach.
Better luck next time.